2026/044: The compliance of building work with Building Code Clause E1.3.1 Surface Water as it relates to protection of other property and the authority’s decision to refuse to issue a notice to fix. - 6 Oakum Road, Whitby, Porirua

Abbreviation
2026/044
Valid from
3/11/2026

Information provider
Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment,
Information type
Determination,
Format
PDF,

Description

This determination considers whether building work carried out at 6 Oakum Road complies with Clause E1.3.1 in relation to the protection of ‘other property’ and the authority’s decision to refuse to issue a notice to fix.

The determination considers whether surface water collected and concentrated by the building work is disposed of in a way that avoids the likelihood of nuisance or damage to 4 Oakum Road.

Decision

In accordance with section 188 of the Building Act 2004, the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment determines,

  • the building work at 6 Oakum Road does not comply with clauses E1.3.1 and E1.3.3 as they relate to the protection of other property, and
  • the nature and effects of the non-compliance, including the effects already experienced on other property and the ongoing risk of those effects recurring, warranted the issue of a notice to fix requiring the noncompliance to be remedied, and accordingly I reverse the authority’s decision.

For assistance with locating previous versions, please contact the information provider.
View on Information Provider website Download this resource (PDF, 162KB)
For assistance with locating previous versions, please contact the information provider.
This resource is not cited by any other resources.

2026/044: The compliance of building work with Building Code Clause E1.3.1 Surface Water as it relates to protection of other property and the authority’s decision to refuse to issue a notice to fix. - 6 Oakum Road, Whitby, Porirua

This document is not CITED BY any other resources:

2026/044: The compliance of building work with Building Code Clause E1.3.1 Surface Water as it relates to protection of other property and the authority’s decision to refuse to issue a notice to fix. - 6 Oakum Road, Whitby, Porirua

Description

This determination considers whether building work carried out at 6 Oakum Road complies with Clause E1.3.1 in relation to the protection of ‘other property’ and the authority’s decision to refuse to issue a notice to fix.

The determination considers whether surface water collected and concentrated by the building work is disposed of in a way that avoids the likelihood of nuisance or damage to 4 Oakum Road.

Decision

In accordance with section 188 of the Building Act 2004, the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment determines,

  • the building work at 6 Oakum Road does not comply with clauses E1.3.1 and E1.3.3 as they relate to the protection of other property, and
  • the nature and effects of the non-compliance, including the effects already experienced on other property and the ongoing risk of those effects recurring, warranted the issue of a notice to fix requiring the noncompliance to be remedied, and accordingly I reverse the authority’s decision.

View on Information Provider website Download this resource (PDF, 162KB)
2026/044: The compliance of building work with Building Code Clause E1.3.1 Surface Water as it relates to protection of other property and the authority’s decision to refuse to issue a notice to fix. - 6 Oakum Road, Whitby, Porirua
Description

This determination considers whether building work carried out at 6 Oakum Road complies with Clause E1.3.1 in relation to the protection of ‘other property’ and the authority’s decision to refuse to issue a notice to fix.

The determination considers whether surface water collected and concentrated by the building work is disposed of in a way that avoids the likelihood of nuisance or damage to 4 Oakum Road.

Decision

In accordance with section 188 of the Building Act 2004, the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment determines,

  • the building work at 6 Oakum Road does not comply with clauses E1.3.1 and E1.3.3 as they relate to the protection of other property, and
  • the nature and effects of the non-compliance, including the effects already experienced on other property and the ongoing risk of those effects recurring, warranted the issue of a notice to fix requiring the noncompliance to be remedied, and accordingly I reverse the authority’s decision.
View on Information Provider website Download this resource (PDF, 162KB)
This resource does not cite any other resources.

2026/044: The compliance of building work with Building Code Clause E1.3.1 Surface Water as it relates to protection of other property and the authority’s decision to refuse to issue a notice to fix. - 6 Oakum Road, Whitby, Porirua

This resource does not CITE any other resources.
Feedback